Jealousy happens to everyone — yes, even swingers. Here’s how to handle it like a pro, from partner pangs to unexpected envy with your playmates.
So you thought swinging would be all threesomes, moresomes and themed parties, huh? Same. But somewhere between the orgy invite and your partner’s second orgasm, something unexpected shows up – jealousy. And no, you’re not broken for feeling it. In fact, it’s one of the most common, most confusing, and most totally normal parts of this whole open relationship thing. Whether it’s a twinge of envy while watching your partner get their toes curled… or the surprise sting when a playmate doesn’t text back – welcome to the club. Let’s talk about how to deal, how to grow, and how to not torch the group chat over it.
All this and more questionable newbie advice on the Vanilla Swingers podcast.
💚 Jealousy: She’s Not the Villain, She’s the Vibe Check
Let’s be clear – jealousy isn’t a red flag. She’s a messy little messenger showing up uninvited to remind you that you CARE. She doesn’t mean your relationship is broken or that you’re not “lifestyle ready.” She just means you’re a real-life human with real-life feelings who just watched their partner make out with a MILF in 6-inch heels or a hottie major who’s 15 years your junior. It’s not jealousy that wrecks things – it’s what you do with it that counts.
🧠 Is It a Threat… or Just a Tantrum?
Cue the inner spiral – “Why is he touching her like that?!” Deep breaths. This is the moment to ask: Is this a legit problem, or just my lizard brain having a panic attack? If a boundary’s been broken – time to talk. But if you’re just feeling a little triggered because someone else made your partner smile? That’s not betrayal, babes. That’s your inner toddler needing a snack and a nap. Harrumph!
PSST! Don't Miss!
New to Swinging? Here's How Not to Suck
💬 Talk First, Freak Out Later
Look, we’ve all gone quiet in the Uber home before. Some of us even have freak-out moments (ahem, Kat!) But let’s skip that whole pouty spiral and actually talk. Say the weird stuff out loud. “I got in my head when you were with her” is way more helpful than “Whatever, it’s fine.”
PRO TIP: Bring it up before you’re 4 drinks deep and spiraling. Lifestyle rule #1 – nothing kills a vibe faster than unspoken resentment wearing a fishnet bodysuit. Share, share, overshare, and share some more.
🔄 Jealous of Your Play Partner? Oh Honey, It Happens
Here’s the plot twist they don’t put in the FAQs – jealousy isn’t just for your spouse. Say whattttt??!!! That hot couple you had amazing chemistry with? You might feel a way when they ghost, or when they have toe-curling play with someone else. It’s “non-monogamous possessiveness” and it’s more common than you think, especially when you lean monogamish, like us! Everyone wants to feel like their #1 – so when ENM brings others to play, it can shoot some barbs to the heart. The trick? Stay present and enjoy the connection for what it is – not what you hope it might become. Just because the sexy fun is magical doesn’t mean you’re soulmates. Ride the high, don’t build a castle on it.
🗣️ Don’t Compare, Don’t Overshare
Here’s a little PSA that’ll save you from unnecessary drama: your play partner is not your confessional booth. It’s one thing to be open—it’s another to casually drop “you’re great, but last weekend’s foursome was insane!” Like, ma’am. Sir. No one asked. Unless your current partner explicitly says “tell me all the juicy details,” maybe don’t monologue about how your last playdate rocked your world. Same goes for gushing about your own partner. We get it, your SO gives great head—but if you’re mid-flirt or mid-f**k with someone else, maybe… read the room? The goal is to make the person in front of you feel like a damn snack, not a side dish to someone else’s highlight reel. Keep it sexy. Keep it present. Keep the commentary to your group chat.
💞 Compersion: Lifestyle’s Secret Weapon
Compersion is like spinach. Good for you, hard to swallow. But when it hits? Mmm, delicious. It’s that warm “I’m happy because you’re happy” feeling. Doesn’t mean you won’t have moments of “why her and not me?” but it does mean you can feel those things and still celebrate your partner’s pleasure. Practice makes perfect. Or at least tolerable.
🔮 Mirror, Mirror, WTF Am I Feeling?
The truth bomb? You will get jealous again. It doesn’t mean the lifestyle isn’t for you – it means you’re doing the messy, beautiful work of growing. And yeah, sometimes growth looks like fighting in a Waffle House parking lot at 3am. But more often? It looks like better sex, deeper love, and realizing that feelings don’t make you weak. They make you real.
✅ Kat's Final Thoughts
Jealousy isn’t a dealbreaker – it’s an opportunity. An annoying, inconvenient, sometimes mascara-streaking opportunity. But if you face it, talk about it, and give it space to breathe, it stops being a monster under the bed and starts being part of the dance. It can’t hurt you if it’s out in the open! You’re not failing the lifestyle because you caught feelings. You’re just doing it with your eyes wide open. And babes? That’s hot.
Find all of this and more on this episode of our top-rated swingers podcast for new couples to the lifestyle, the Vanilla Swingers podcast!
Swinger Lingo (check Swinger Dictionary for more!)
Compersion: The ultimate feel-good vibe in the world of non-monogamy, where seeing your partner’s pleasure brings a smile to your face and a flutter to your heart.
Monogamish: A tantalizing twist on traditional monogamy, where a committed couple dabbles in a bit of playful exploration with others. It’s all about keeping the main relationship spicy while enjoying occasional, consensual fun on the side.
◀️ Previous Episode Next Episode ▶️